In partnership with

There’s something quietly unsettling happening in modern marketing. You feed a prompt into your favorite AI tool—whether it's for copy, visuals, or even campaign strategy—and what you get back feels… familiar. It’s not bad. In fact, it’s often good. But rarely is it bold, strange, or exceptional.

This, right here, is the AI feedback loop in action.

As marketers, we’re increasingly relying on AI tools trained on vast datasets of what’s already been done. These tools are designed to optimize for what’s been most successful, most liked, most clicked. That might sound efficient.

But there’s a catch:

🚧 The Mediocrity Trap

Here’s how it works:

1. AI is trained on existing content — most of which sits in the middle of the bell curve.

2. You use AI to generate new content — which, by design, mimics what’s worked before.

3. That content performs okay, and becomes part of the dataset that future AI models learn from.

4. Rinse and repeat — until originality becomes the exception, not the rule.

It’s a loop that gradually smooths out the edges of creativity. And in a world where differentiation is everything, that’s a real problem.

🎨 Why This Hurts Creativity

Think about the campaigns that truly broke through in the past decade. The ones that made you feel something. They probably:

• took a risk

• defied conventional formats

• spoke to culture in a timely, human way

• weren’t afraid to be weird or uncomfortable

Now ask yourself: Could a generative AI model have produced those?

Unlikely.

Because when AI is used passively—as a faster way to create “content”—it rewards the average. It plays it safe. And when the industry does the same, marketing becomes background noise.

🔓 Breaking the Loop

We’re not here to ditch AI. We’re here to reclaim creativity from the loop.

Here’s how modern marketers can do it:

1. Feed it the right source material

Train or prompt your AI models using your own best work, not generic web content. What you feed it is what it learns from. If you want bold ideas, give it bold input.

2. Use AI to prototype, not publish

Treat AI like your brainstorming assistant—not your creative director. Use it to explore directions, generate “what ifs,” or challenge assumptions. But let the final call rest with human instinct.

3. Build in weirdness

Seriously.

Add randomness, contradiction, surprise. These are elements that spark emotional resonance and signal originality. Don’t be afraid to prompt AI with “unexpected,” “disruptive,” or “unpopular” angles.

4. Question performance metrics

If you’re always optimizing for likes or clicks, you’ll loop back into sameness. Recalibrate your success metrics to reward impact, storytelling, and brand distinctiveness, not just performance.

⚡️ A Moment for Modern Marketers

At its best, AI should be like a skilled intern—fast, helpful, and full of suggestions—but not the one deciding your brand’s tone, values, or creative vision.

Because let’s be honest: The future of marketing belongs to those who know when to trust the machine—and when to break away from it.

And as modern marketers, that’s our edge.

Final Thoughts

In 2025, brands will win not by being faster, but by being truer. Don’t settle for average. Push for the idea that feels risky, strange, or raw—because that’s where originality lives.

And when AI starts looping back the same old stuff?

Loop out. You’ve got better instincts.

Hit reply or DM me. I’d love to hear from you!

Share your thoughts, experiences, or questions about modern marketing.

Comment below if you’re reading it on our website or hit reply if you’re reading it in your inbox .

🔍 What it’s about:

In a world where generative AI tools are becoming table stakes, the real competitive advantage is shifting from using AI to guiding it better. In the next edition, we’ll explore how the art and science of prompt engineering is reshaping how modern marketers brief, ideate, and build campaigns. Think of it as creative direction—but for machines.

🧠 Why this matters:

Prompt engineering is fast becoming a critical thinking skill for marketers. It's not about being more technical—it's about asking smarter questions, framing clearer ideas, and unlocking better outputs from AI. This edition will show you how to do just that.

Stay tuned.

The future of marketing isn't just AI-powered—it's prompt-precise.

What topics would you want to see here?

Hit reply (if you’re reading it in email) or leave a comment (if you’re reading it on the web) and tell me what topics, brands, or case studies you would want me to analyze, and I'll add them to my list of ideas. You’ll also get a shout-out.